Return to Amish

The pandemic has forced Jeremiah, Carmela, Ada and Sabrina to come together in Florida. Sabrina prepares for the arrival of her second child, while Jeremiah and Jethro must make peace. Rosanna and Maureen decide to leave their Amish communities.

Ada takes Maureen and Rosanna to the ocean for the first time, but Rosanna contemplates returning to her Amish community. Jeremiah connects with his biological father, and an unexpected guest threatens Sabrina and Jethro's baby shower.

While questioning his own father's legitimacy, Jeremiah discusses having a baby with Carmela. Maureen and Rosanna are in awe of the rich English. Sabrina is afraid something is wrong with the baby, and she must head to the hospital alone due to COVID-19.

After hours alone in labor, Sabrina must have an emergency C-section. Roseanna has had enough of hearing about Maureen's new beau, which leads to a heated fight. Still having doubts about his biological father, Jeremiah asks Dennis to take a DNA test.

Jeremiah learns the truth about his father. Rosanna and Maureen buy their first bathing suits, but then they learn that they must leave Florida abruptly. Sabrina confronts Jethro after finding text messages on his phone.

While out with new friends, Rosanna gets asked out on a date. Maureen has her first kiss, but she has reservations about going further. Jeremiah meets his biological cousin. Jethro walks out on Sabrina and their kids.

After a night of passion with Daniel, Maureen worries about an abnormal itch. Sabrina and Jethro have an emotional face-off. Jeremiah meets his biological cousin. Rosanna goes on her first date.

Maureen and Rosanna must decide to go English or stay Amish. Jeremiah comes face-to-face with his biological cousins for the first time. While Sabrina is trying to salvage her relationship with Jethro, others are slower to absolve him of his sins.

Maureen's Amish parents deliver a blow, but she feels support from new love Daniel. Rosanna realizes that her decision to leave the Amish community will affect everyone in her family. Sabrina wrestles with whether Jethro will fall back into his old ways.

Ada throws a party to celebrate Maureen and Rosanna's English makeovers. When Jeremiah reveals he wants to be a father, Carmela's answer could make or break their marriage. Sabrina and Jethro try to fix their relationship, but a secret changes everything.